Carbon Steel and Stainless Steel Frying Pans

We have compared carbon steel and a stainless steel frying pan with some other frying pans and explained which frying pan is best suited to your kitchen and how to use it.

The frying pan is an essential piece of cookware, that completes every kitchen. Healthy food is a basic need of life as hygienic food can give us a healthy life, and on the contrary, contaminated food can make us sick. You can use a frying pan for searing meats, baking, grilling, and frying.

The biggest problem is choosing the right frying pan for your cooking. Different frying pans made of different metals are available in the markets, including Carbon Steel, Stainless Steel, Cast Iron, Ceramic, nonstick, and Aluminum frying pans, of which, Carbon Steel and Stainless Steel Frying Pans are the most popular.

The FDA warned that synthetic nonstick coatings used in nonstick frying pans are harmful to health because it is made from poisonous chemicals like Teflon, PFOA, and PFAS can cause many cancer diseases. The good news is that chemical-free frying pans are now available in the markets, so there is no risk of chemicals leaching into food.

Each cooking vessel has an expiration date, after which it should be disposed of; otherwise, it can be a threat to your health. Similarly, there is a specific way to use every cookware.

Also Read: Humidity Thermometer | 5 Best | Buyers Guide

Buyer’s Guide:

Carbon steel and stainless steel frying pans are popularly used for home kitchens and restaurants. Besides having some fantastic identical features, both of these frying pans have some other distinctive features.

Popular features:

Carbon steel and stainless frying pans are lifetime transferable cookware. Stainless steel pans are feather-light and easy to carry than carbon steel pans as a 10-12 inch stainless steel skillet is considered the most satisfactory utensil in contrast to carbon steel skillets, the ideal size is about eight inches.

Natural Nonstick Coatings:

What is unique about these two metal frying pans is that they have their natural nonstick coatings, and carbon steel and stainless steel are free of synthetic toxic nonstick coatings, so no chemical leaching occurs.

Easy Cleaning:

Stainless steel skillet can accept the method of a dishwasher, thus saving you precious time while, on the contrary, carbon steel skillet needs to be cleaned by hand, and carbon steel pans should be protected from the dishwasher otherwise their natural coating will be removed, and it will corrode rapidly.

Heat Resistant Ability:

The companies recommend different temperature ranges for different metal cookware. Similarly, carbon steel is an intense heat-tolerating skillet. It can be used in a highly heated oven, but the temperature should not exceed 572F, on the other hand, stainless steel skillets can’t bear intense heat and require low to moderate heat for cooking.

Carbon Steel Vs. Stainless Steel Frying Pan

Carbon steel is a combination of iron and carbon, comprising 98.5% iron and only 1% of carbon. This pan can tolerate high temperatures and has an extended expiration date. Carbon steel is comparatively light in weight than stainless steel and is more sensitive to salty and acidic foods like vinegar, lemon, tomatoes, sugar, etc.

Furthermore, you cannot leave your carbon frying pans in water because doing so will spoil their natural nonstick coating and cause it to rust. On the other hand, stainless steel comprises iron and chromium and is highly resistant to rust, so it also lasts a very long time.

You can easily cook acidic foods with stainless steel pans and leave them in water without any hassle, but stainless steel skillet is a little more expensive than carbon steel skillet.

Is Carbon Steel Better Than Stainless Steel?

Although being a sturdy, long-lasting metal, and having many other useful features, carbon steel is more susceptible to rust and is suitable for dishwashing machines, but stainless steel is dishwasher proof and has high resistance capacity against rust. Both metals are good with their specific properties.

Is Carbon Steel Safe For Cooking?

Carbon steel has its natural nonstick coating, which is chemical-free, moreover, carbon steel helps seeping iron into your food, which is an  essential mineral for blood production (hemoglobin), and thus cooking with carbon steel cookware is useful even physician recommend carbon steel utensils to enjoy a healthy life.

Stainless Steel Frying Pan Vs. Nonstick Frying Pan

Nonstick frying pans are with its satiny, polished coatings that are easy to handle, and it doesn’t let the eggs stick to the underside of the pan. It requires low or moderate heat and cannot bear high heat as fitness fanatic chefs love to use nonstick cookware for cooking natural food like eggs, beans, crepes, pancakes, and pasta.

Metal spatulas are not recommended for nonstick pans as these spatulas remove nonstick coatings. EPA and Food Network.com declared that these nonstick coatings are no longer poisonous.

Stainless steel, on the other hand, contains a natural non-chemical coating and is used for cooking steaks, chicken, chops, and turkeys. The proper way to use stainless steel is first to heat it enough and then cook food with it. The only issue is that earlier heat-up, and too much oiling is mandatory for stainless steel frying pans.

Is Cast Iron Nonstick?

Cast iron is a good substitute for nonstick cookware, but it also possesses its natural nonstick coating that can be maintained for a long time if it is continuously seasoned. This cookware like other nonstick requires preheating according to the recommended temperature. Cast iron is perfect for baking pancakes, biscuits, pies, and pan pizzas.

Non-stick Vs. Cast iron

 Cast iron pan possesses its natural shiny nonstick coating and stays hot for a long time, but nonstick pan has a synthetic nonstick coating. It doesn’t have the ability to keep warm for long because of the aluminum base, which cools it down instantly. Nonstick cookware is not as reliable as cast iron, which can be used over and over again for a century.

Is Black Residue On Cast Iron Pan/Skillet Bad?

Black residue on cast iron formed by sticky food and burnt oil is harmless, but it is not removed. It will spoil the food taste and make the clothes dirty. To avoid black residue, as

 cast iron must be seasoned consistently.

Difference between Stainless Steel and Steel

Both of these metals are widely used worldwide as they differ in price, firmness, flexibility, etc. Steel is a mixture of iron and carbon, which makes it stable while the presence of chromium elements in stainless steel makes it more resistant to corrosion. Steel is more robust and inexpensive than stainless steel.

Does Grey Cast Iron Rust?

Grey iron is a form of cast iron that comprises carbon, silicon, and graphite, and because of the presence of graphite elements, it turns grey-colored, so it is called grey cast iron. Grey cast iron is less solid than other forms of cast iron, but it does not rust due to its silicone element.

Wrought Iron Vs. Cast Iron

 The simple difference between these two metals is that wrought iron is heated to make it more flexible and bendable and then cast into various shapes, but cast iron is not bendable because of its delicacy and stiffness as cast iron is first completely melted and then cooled in molds and given different ways.

Best Spatula for Cast Iron

Silicon and wooden spatulas are most suitable for cast iron because they don’t damage the natural coating of cast iron. spatulas are widely used for cast iron everywhere, but metal spatulas can damage the natural surface of cast iron.

Stainless Steel Vs. Cast Iron

Stainless steel is lightweight metal than cast steel and is suitable for slow cooking like baking and grilling, but you can cook a variety of daily dishes with stainless steel. Iron needs proper care; otherwise, it becomes a victim of rust, but stainless steel is free from the danger of rust.

Cast Iron Vs. Stainless Steel Grill

Cast iron grates are naturally nonstick and long-lasting with narrow surfaces as compared to stainless steel grates. Stainless grills, along with their natural coating, are rust-free and relatively easy to wash.

Also Read: Manual Coffee Grinder in US: Best 4

Alton Brown Season Cast Iron

Alton Brown season cast iron is an American chef, who suggests Crisco shortening for cast iron as Crisco shortening is pure oil, that is most suitable for seasoning, and unlike the other vegetable oils, it does not stick to the bottom of the pan.

Lodge 15-Inch Cast Iron Skillet

Lodge 15-Inch cast iron skillet is perfect for baking and grilling. It gives you a variety of delicious food without drying them; this skillet is a little heavy, so it contains two beautiful handles. It stays hot for a long time, and you can easily use it on the stove and in the oven.

It’s another impressive feature that it can also be used for browning meat at high temperatures. It enhances the beauty of your kitchen because of its fashionable bold black color and trendy design. This skillet is not recommended for the dishwasher and should not be used in the microwave.

Benefits of Cast Iron Skillet

1. Cast iron skillet has many benefits given below:
2. Being cumbersome and hard metal, it keeps hot for a long time
3. Cast iron skillet has its natural chemical-free nonstick coating.
4. Its most important benefit is iron leaching into food, which overcomes iron deficiency in the human body and is also an essential element for hemoglobin.
5. It has a long expiration date and can be used generation after generation.
6. It is perfect for both stove and oven cooking.

Difference between Steel and Cast Iron

The main difference between these two metals is that more carbon is present in cast iron, which makes it heavy, rugged, and breakable, but still has a comparatively low carbon content, which is why steel is difficult to cast.

Is Steel Better Than Cast Iron?

Yes, cast iron is ahead of steel because of more carbon in cast iron due to which it can be molded into any shape and steel, on the other hand, contains less carbon content, so it is tough to cast steel. Furthermore, cast iron is not more expensive than steel.

Gotham Steel Pan Seasoning Instructions

Follow the given instructions for proper seasoning of Gotham Steel Pan:

1. First, wash pan after washing your pan by hand, let it dry completely,
2. Spread any vegetable oil all over the nonstick bottom of the pan but avoid using olive oil.
3. After heating up the pan on stove for about 2 minute, let it cool.
4. Remove the extra oil from blotting paper or napkin paper. Now your pan’s natural nonstick coating is ready to use.

Lightweight Cast Iron Skillet

A lightweight cast iron skillet is well-matched with a grill, oven, and stovetop. It is toxic chemical-free, rust-free, and has a long life. Its nit-riding sheet makes it easier to clean, so it is preferred to be used in domestic and hotel kitchens. The best example of this is Zuhne’s lightweight 10 to 12-inch skillet set of cast iron. Which is much lighter than other cast iron cookware.

Can You Put Stainless Steel Pan In The Oven?

Yes! Stainless steel can be placed in the oven as all metals like stainless steel, and carbon steel are oven-safe, but nonmetals are not oven-safe; therefore, they should be avoided putting in the oven.

Carbon Steel Cookware Set

A 7-piece carbon steel nonstick cookware set is considered the best customer’s choice in the world. As it comes with stylish, lightweight back knobs and handles for easy lifting. The food can be easily seen from inside through an oxygenated glass lid. And it’s super easy to clean due to its long-lasting nonstick coating.

Cast Iron Smooth Vs. Rough

 As the name suggests, cooking in smooth cast iron is much easier than cooking in roughcast iron, you can convert roughcast iron into nonstick smooth cast iron by constant proper seasoning. Some people think that roughcast iron cookware accepts seasoning very quickly and becomes well-seasoned nonstick like smooth cast iron cookware.

Wrought Iron Vs. Steel

The major difference between wrought iron vs. steel is that wrought iron contains only iron and steel consists of carbon and alloy. Both are used to make long-lasting fences. Steel is much more solid than wrought iron.

Enameled Cast Iron Vs. Cast Iron

Enameled cast iron is prevalent nowadays, enameled is a stained glossy coating of cast iron. Unlike classic cast iron, enameled cast iron does not require any seasoning method as it is rust-free. Different attractive colors of enameled cast iron like red, blue, black, and white are available in markets. Enameled cast iron cookware is more costly than ordinary cast iron cookware.

Lodge Carbon Steel Skillet

lodge carbon steel skillet heats up very fast and stays hot for a long. It has steel nailed handles, and its nonstick surface can accept metal spatulas. They can be used on stovetop, grills, and ovens in both home kitchens and restaurant kitchens. And they are also perfect for outdoor cooking. They do not need seasoning as they are already nonstick skillets, but they should be washed with hands.

How to add Carbon to Steel?

The Simplest traditional skillet method, that most blacksmiths use to add carbon to steel is to reproduce the steel again. And for this, the carbon-deficient steel is first beaten and then cut into small pieces, and then, these small pieces are heated and re-welded by hammer to get desired results.

Stainless Steel Cookware Pros and Cons

Pros:

Stainless steel is reliable, portable, long-running metal

It doesn’t react with acidic and sour foods

It is more resistant to rust

Cons:

The drawback of stainless steel is leaching the metals into food

Good quality stainless steel cookware is pricey.

Aluminum Vs. Stainless Steel Cookware

Both of these are ovenproof. The main distinction is that aluminum cookware contains synthetic nonstick coating. While stainless steel has its own natural Teflon-free coating.

Ceramic Vs. Stainless Steel Cookware

The significant difference between ceramic and stainless steel cookware is that ceramic cookware comes with synthetic silicon-based nonstick coating. Which is 100% harmless and doesn’t contain any hazardous chemicals. And stainless steel contains a natural nonstick coating chemical-free coating that is purely hygienic. In short, with a little difference, both of these utensils are safe for health.  

Cast Aluminum Vs. Cast Iron Cookware

Aluminum cookware is relatively light in weight, becomes hot instantly, cannot retain heat for so long, and also has a short life span. It is expensive. Cast iron cookware, on the other hand, is heavy in lifting and stays hot so a long. Cast iron cookware with longevity can be passed on from generation to generation, and it is less expensive than aluminum cookware.

Also read: Best Electric Hand Mixers To Get Perfect Whip

Conclusion

The selection of the best frying depends on the food cooked in your home. Each frying pan has its unique features and plays a vivifying role in your kitchen. Carbon steel and stainless steel frying pans are high in demand these days due to their ideal characteristics.

Both of these frying pans are chemical-free without synthetic nonstick coatings, which are toxic to human health. I suggest, if you want to enjoy every meal, then carbon steel and stainless steel frying pans must be available in your kitchen. Both of these can be easily used on the stovetop as well as in the oven.

Carbon steel frying pan is most suitable for veggies, searing meats, steaks, and egg dishes; on the other hand, stainless steel is perfect for stews and sauces.